Just in Time
Playing at Circle in the Square Theatre
Musical or play? Musical
Lottery or Rush Tickets? $40.00 In Person Rush Tickets
What I Paid: $199.00
My Rating: ★★★★
Official Website: https://justintimebroadway.com/
Tony Award® winner Jonathan Groff (Merrily We Roll Along, Hamilton) is back on Broadway and is “onstage perfection” (Chicago Tribune) as Bobby Darin, the legendary singer whose short but remarkable life took him from teen idol to global sensation. Developed and directed by Tony Award winner Alex Timbers (Moulin Rouge!, Beetlejuice), with a book by Warren Leight and Isaac Oliver, Just In Time is an “utterly electrifying” (Entertainment Weekly) new musical that immerses audiences into an intimate nightclub “so seductive in ambiance that you find yourself not wanting to go back outside” (Chicago Tribune). Complete with iconic Bobby Darin hits including “Beyond the Sea,” “Mack the Knife,” “Splish Splash,” and “Dream Lover,” Just In Time is “a helluva good time at the theater” (Time Out).
REVIEW
If not for Jonathan Groff starring in this bio-jukebox musical chronicling the life and career of Bobby Darin, I would not have spent a Tuesday night in the basement of Wicked. Thankfully, Groff was enough to lure me to the Circle in the Square for a one-of-a-kind Broadway experience that will always have a special place in my heart.
I purchased a full price ticket in advance directly from the box office online, as Just in Time has been selling over capacity consistently since its run began. Since this theatre is set up primarily in the round, there really isn’t a bad seat in the house. I was in Row F on the left side of the main stage, and had a fully, unobstructed view. The cast also moves around the entire floor section quite a bit throughout the show, so many audience members have the opportunity to be in the Groff “splash zone” at one point or another. If you do choose to splurge on table seats, the actors will likely interact with you, and you will essentially be part of the show.
Similarly, the set and theatre really create a unique experience for Broadway-goers. From the moment you walk into the nightclub-like set-up, you feel as if you have entered a different dimension. This is amplified by the show itself, as Groff breaks the fourth wall right from the start of the show by introducing himself as the actor who will be playing your Bobby Darin, and by sharing his personal connection to the music. Not only does this interaction create a special bond with the audience, but Groff goes so far as to outright mention how the magic of live theatre is encompassed in what happens inside the room at that specific moment, as it can never again be recreated in the same way. As someone who shares this sentiment, I found it quite emotional to hear these words out loud.
Moreover, the plot of Just in Time is similar to other musicals of the same vein, following the life of Bobby Darin while featuring his music throughout the show. While I did learn a lot about Darin, and found myself very touched at certain moments, I also felt myself thinking that this style of musical is overdone. Similar to The Neil Diamond Musical A Beautiful Noise, which I saw in 2023, the best moments of Just in Time are the big musical numbers. I’m not sure how I feel about these biographical shows focusing on people who yearn to be famous all while making questionable decisions, such as Darin essentially stealing from other artists in an attempt to gain popularity. Perhaps Just in Time is a good reminder that those musicians who seem larger than life are mere humans after all.
In the end, I left Just in Time grateful to have experienced a few hours in the presence of Jonathan Groff. He is in his element in this show, and it is clear he is born to be a performer. That being said, it will be interesting to see if Just in Time has a life outside of Groff. The show is, in many ways, built around him as a person, and likely requires some rewrites if another star steps into the leading role. Thus, if you have the opportunity (and the funds!) to see Just in Time, I do think Groff is worth the price of admission, and he is very well supported by a talented cast and band.
STAGE DOOR
The Stage Door at the Circle in the Square is directly to your left when you exit. There will be barricades set up around the perimeter, and security will keep you well informed along the way. We were told that some of the performers do sign Playbills, but that Jonathan has never come out at Stage Door. We were very fortunate to have four cast members sign our Playbills: Lance Roberts, Emily Bergl, Gracie Lawrence, and Ericka Henningsen. This Stage Door experience was not only well organized, but all of the audience members were polite and respectful. It was a great way to end the night.
See my vlog from Just in Time on Instagram HERE.